Beyond mathematics.. the Change Equation and Kepa’s refusal
by Kurt Lindley
26 February 2019
I have been really looking forward to this blog and exploring the ‘Change Equation’. (Don’t you just love it when maths enters into the world of organisational and people development?!) We recognise that ‘meaningful’ change is more complex than a maths question, however the Change Equation (defined through the work of Beckhard and latterly Dannemiller) give us a great methodology to explore the extent to which people, teams and organisations are in a position for/to change.
In our previous blog ‘reactions to change’ we recognised that change is constant (‘life is flux’), so why do some find themselves clinging to the now, like glue binding us to people, objects, processes, systems or situations that no longer serve us?
Well here’s Dannemillar’s formula for sustainable change (D x V x F) > R
D = Dissatisfaction, V = Vision, F = First Steps, R = Resistance
The premise being that, successful organisational (or individual) change is only possible when the product of D, V and F, is greater than the resistance to change.
Keeping things all mathematical, lets imagine D = Dissatisfaction, V = Vision, F = First Steps are all vectors, ‘What’, I here you say. Here’s a simple definition for our context below:
A vector – a quantity having direction as well as magnitude (note – said vector will continue in a given direction until acted upon by and opposing force).
Vector: This vector represents a dissatisfaction with the status quo. The level of dissatisfaction needed to support significant change efforts must be high. This is the motivational factor with in the formula, the desire for change (the WHY).
The opposing force: Satisfaction is the opposing force in this scenario, a happiness with the current context. Note if an employee is happy with their current world, why would they change?
Action: Our role here is to create a willingness for change. Position change as something being done with and not to people, explain the value of change through 3 lenses:
The effect on the organisation – sustainability, growth, diversification
The effect on the client – better services and return purchase
The effect on the employee – increased income, improved working environment
Vector: this vector represents the need for a compelling Vision regarding a positive future state (internal or organisational) that each individual can paint themselves into. It should represent something people would like to be a part of and want to make happen. A clear and shared illustration of the possible futures (The What)
Opposing Force: The opposing force to vision is confusion. Without clarity there is fog and people find themselves in the wilderness. If they can’t see the path, why would they take it? (there present is a known entity and will stick here).
Action: Build awareness of positive futures which are tangible/concrete, share these directly with people, allow them time to internalise them. Paint a vivid picture of this future and make the path crystal clear.
Vector: The vector of ‘First Steps’ is about making it clear what these look like in the realisation of the vision. There is a need to consider not just the plan for but also the ability of others to take these steps. Create a roadmap of acceptable ‘first steps’ and longer-term actions (The How)
Opposing Force: Our nemesis here is friction, an increasing desire to remain static, particularly if the first step is too big.
Action: show how as a collective the vision will be achieved, the steps, the investment, the impact on peoples now and collective tomorrow. This plan must include the first step and the second song (check out our Dancing Guy Blog).
Working with Change
We find people resist change when:
They believe they ‘lose’… lose value, status, belonging
Trust is lacking within those ‘imposing’ the change
Half a story exists and the ‘why’ behind the change is not clear
Implications of change on a personal level are unknown
They believe (and have evidence) change is bad
A very recent sporting example played out in the final of the Carabao Cup on Sunday. Chelsea goalkeeper Kepa Arrizabalaga resisted manager Maurizio Sarri’s attempt to substitute him late in extra time of the Carabao Cup final, in extraordinary scenes.
In this situation, we can only guess that Kepa (goalkeeper) was happy (satisfied) with the situation, he couldn’t see vision for the change, so the first step (to leave the pitch) was too far too dramatic so he showed his resistance.
It is widely acknowledged that the most effective method of supporting change/dealing with resistance is to engage stakeholders in shaping change. So simply ask:
How do you feel about the current status quo (in general/specifics)? Understand their Satisfaction/Dissatisfaction
Can you visualise yourself in a positive future state once the change has been implemented? Appreciate their current status and future Vision
What needs to happen to start your journey towards that vision? Identify their First Steps
What will stop you from taking those steps/from embracing the change? Extrovert to understand their Resistance
This will give you the insight you need to build commitment for change and gather momentum to shift to new spaces.
JULY NEWS! Here's a round up of all the exciting things that have been going on at Leading Edge in July 2021📰. Find out more ...about what we're doing and how we work here: https://bit.ly/2VVdGTv #highperformance #wellbeing #coaching #leadership #teamtraining #testimonials
Today marks the start of the Toyko 2020 Olympics.🏅 We’ve collaborated with the British Olympic Association since 2018? Our ...TeamEDGE collaboration brings the DNA of Olympic success to high performance organisations and individuals. Find out more here: https://bit.ly/3zhaaBy
Leadership is an action, not a position. Do you agree? 🏆 We describe ourselves as ‘action leaders not thought leaders’ ...– our value is measured by a shift in performance, not process. Get in touch today to find out more https://bit.ly/3yv7Sy0 #leadingedge #leadershipskills
We believe that people aren't broken. With our support and expertise we can help to curate great relationships and create ...memorable experiences for your team. 🤝 #leadershipbyexample #leadershipfirst #performance #clients #coaching
We have worked with England Rugby since 2017, focusing on character and leadership development for the U20s – England’s next ...generation.🏉
Here’s what our Director Patrick Marr had to say about the whole experience👇🏼
You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.